Rigid Heddle Loom Review updated

25 10 2008

Since publishing the Rigid Heddle Loom review, I have woven on/with the Kromski Fiddle, and the Harp, and wanted to update the review, with these looms.  I also want to say that I read recently that some floor loom weavers consider rigid heddle looms to be ‘toys’.  Well, they are fun, they are small, they generally provide a quick weave,  so my rigid heddle looms are my toys.  My floor looms are my toys, and my tapestry loom is my toy.  My work is my play.  And I do a LOT of it.  Don’t worry about what others think.  How much fun are you having?

OK, to review the looms:

Beka.  It’s a a simple loom.  I like the Beka because it’s an inexpensive way to have rigid heddle looms to take from art center to art center without renting a larger vehicle.  They are lightweight, and graceful looking. These looms assemble in less than 5 minutes.  The ratchet brake is fairly secure, but the end of the 2 beams screw into the side supports, and (Dislikes) these tend to tighten themselves so the warp doesn’t advance without working with them every time.  The block that holds the rigid heddle up, or down, is just that, a block of wood, as a result, the heddle slips off a good deal.  I also don’t find it comfortable as a lap loom.  It just doesn’t rest well against the table, and if tilted, the rigid heddle is even less likely to stay in the up or down position.  If you have the money for a better loom, don’t spend your money here. This loom should cost approx $110 for a 20″, and $127 for a 24′ .  Included equipment are 2 stick shuttles, a pickup stick, and a threading hook.  Be aware: No warping device is included!

Schacht rigid heddle looms Schacht is an ok lap loom.  Again, it’s very rudimentary, streamline, and graceful looking. It’s very light weight, and easy to travel with.  I like the Schacht for the same reason I liked the Beka.  I also like the fact that Schacht notches the block that holds the rigid heddle up, or down.    As you know, anything with the Schacht name is not “economy” priced. I dislike it because it is rather an economy loom,by design, yet at nearly twice the price of the Beka. The warp brake is tightened by screwing the block on the back beam, which allows slippage, leading to frustration in my classes.  So between the price, and the slippage, I don’t use Schacht. It comes with a clamp, warping peg, stick shuttle, and threading hook. Generally, these looms cost approx $180 for a 20″ loom, and $200 for a 25″ loom.

Kromski Harp is a lovely loom.  I didn’t plan on liking either Kromski because the hinged loom seems like a rather silly idea to me.  LIkes:The rigid heddle loom is already so much smaller than other looms, why hinge it.  Yet one of my students who travels a lot said, “simple, to fly with it”.  Yes, it would travel better in that small state. I began liking the loom as soon as I finished putting it together.  The wood is finished.  The various supports are turned wood, or otherwise decorative, there is a system with the loom to assist in threading, the loom comes with a nice heddle/reed hook, a DVD, clear instructions, a pretty rigid heddle, clear assembly instructions, warping devices and shuttles.  It’s a good deal.  I got the 16″ for $189, which is a good price for a package that includes everything you need.  Dislikes: I didn’t like the density of the reed, but that’s because I’m so fond of the Leclercs, which come with a more widely sett reed.  I’m concerned the hinge will come loose.  I can’t figure out how to carry the loom, as the hooks come unhooked when the loom is folded.  You pretty much have to buy a carry bag to keep the stuff together (good thing they sell one).  I have enjoyed it in the few days I’ve had it.  It is the only rigid heddle loom that I’ve bought to teach on that just beckoned me to use after class.  I will buy more of these if this holds up.  It’s actually a good buy.

Ashford Knitter’s Loom never got reviewed in the original or update because it seemed so much like the Kromski. I have now taught on one, and it’s not a Kromski. The knitter’s loom has a unique feature in the fact that it folds partially to weave.  I don’t see this as a pro or con to the loom. Unlike the Kromski, there is no device to hold your warping rod while threading the heddle. Of course this is because Ashford ships the loom with a single warping peg, and instructions for direct warping. In small homes, this is not always the best way. Actually, I always prefer to pre-measure my warp on a board. And, when teaching, the space requirements for direct warping are ridiculous.  I like Ashford and would not overly discourage someone from getting this loom, but would recommend the Kromski, Bergere, or Penelope over this loom. I don’t see any specific benefit this loom offers that one cannot find in any other rigid heddle loom. It is a nice, functional loom. Comes with warping peg, heddle hook, reed hook, clamps and instructions.  Additional heddles, and stand are available, as is a carry-all.

Kromski Fiddle is a cheaper alternative if you want a Kromski, but don’t want a hinged loom.  It’s a comfortable loom to use.  I got the 16″ version for about $130. It comes with the hook, a warping peg, shuttles, and assembly instructions, as well as that cool system for holding the apron rod to make warping easier.  It is simpler to assemble than the harp.  Dislikes: The wood is unfinished. It does not come with use instructions, or a DVD.  The heddle is very closely sett, and Too bad.  I will use both the Kromski looms again.  Very good loom.  I would pay more, and be more likely to buy this again, as well as recommend it if it were finished wood, and if it came with some use instructions.  Overall, it’s a very good loom.

Ashford has a nice looking loom.  It’s a lot like the harp without the warping board attached.  I thought I was really going to like it.  It looks rather modern with it’s colorful ratchets and it’s wonderful instruction booklet. Another nice thing about this loom, is that the craftsmanship is quality.  The looms are soundly constructed, finished nicely, and fairly well designed.  The very best feature of the Ashford Rigid Heddle looms, is the clear, instruction manual that accompanies the looms.  A full color instruction booklet that is nearly failsafe is priceless for self-taught beginners.  This is a wonderful feature!  For some reason, however, I find the ratchet/dog system failed me several times, and winding on the warp is not a simple task, because the loom doesn’t have a crank on the warp beam.  All of the above mentioned looms are simple in design, and structurally should make very good lap looms.  I found this one is the best lap loom. It rests easily on the table, and the heddle stays firmly in place when the warp is sufficiently tight.The 24″ runs about 165.00 and it comes with 2 stick shuttles, 2 threading hooks, a clamp, and the precious INSTRUCTIONS!

Leclerc Bergere is a tabletop rigid heddle loom.  It has metal ratchets, and dogs, handles to wind the warp on, and the rigid heddle securely rests in the notched “castle post”.  It’s a more complex design than the aforementioned rigid heddle looms in that it is raised off the table by legs, and has a castle type device for the heddle, rather than simply a support block.  It comes with a styrene boat shuttle, 2, 28″ long stick shuttles, metal lea sticks, a set of 2 warping blocks (each has 2 pegs for creating a cross in your warp), and warp sticks with cord.  As you can see, this is a loom, and if you want to learn the entire process of warping, this is a great place to start.  You get a lot of equipment for a weaving studio, and a very good table top rigid heddle loom.  I really like this loom.  It’s good for me because as an instructor who travels to art centers(that don’t own looms) to teach, I can take a loom that I can actually teach the entire process of dressing a loom on, and it translates to the student’s floor loom also, because the loom is designed to be dressed back to front like a floor loom.  The rigid heddle rests firmly in the notches, and there is a ‘rest’ position for threading it.  it travels well with the loom warped by simply putting rubber bands around the joint where the rigid heddle rests in the castle post.  It comes with a very clear, thorough instruction booklet that will easily get a beginner started with the loom, and with some elemental tapestry techniques.  However, what I don’t like, is that it is not graceful and complact.  It doesn’t have a simple design, and really isn’t a lap loom.  Also, although I like Leclerc looms a lot, the craftsmanship on the older Leclerc looms is better.  The craftsmanship on the loom is rudimentary.  At just $165, this 24″ loom stands head and shoulders above the others for my purposes. (best overall rigid heddle loom in this review)

Leclerc Penelope II is a rigid heddle tapestry loom.  It is weaves 22.5″ and works as an upright double rigid heddle loom.  It can be used with a single rigid heddle, but comes equipped with 2.  The craftsmanship is very good on this loom, the beams are braked with metal ratchets and dogs, the beams also have cranks for easy beaming of the warp.  As the loom is designed to be used vertically, the rigid heddle supports are designed to hold the heddles securely in this position.  The loom is designed to be warped with lea sticks, and in a ‘back to front’ fashion.  Again, this makes it a wonderful pre-cursor to a floor loom, if that is the direction the weaver is headed.  This loom gives very good tension on the warp, and is comfortable for a variety of tapestry techniques for tapestry, but is not an efficient loom as a substitute for plain weave, or pattern weaving quickly because of it’s upright position.  I’m very impressed with this loom.  It comes with tapestry bobbins, metal lea sticks, 2 warping blocks, which have 2 pegs each, for creating a cross in your warp, heddle hook, and 2 long stick shuttles.  Now, for the downside, it also comes with an instruction booklet that has instructions for the Penelope, but not the Penelope II.  As of the date of this review, I had not been able to get instructions from the company on how to use the 2nd rigid heddle with the loom, as the instructions are for a single rigid heddle design.  Thanks to Schacht for the clear instructions on how to thread a 2 heddle rigid heddle loom. What do I not like about this loom?  As I mentioned, it’s not for someone who wants to ‘crank out’ rigid heddle work. Other than that, I can’t come up with a single thing I don’t like. It’s definitely a rigid heddle loom for the tapestry weave, or a weaver who wants to do 4 harness work on a rigid heddle loom.  .  At $235, this loom is a bargain. (I own 5 of them, and am getting ready to order 3 more… mostly for teaching, but occassionally, for some ‘me’ time).Excellent loom


Actions

Information

6 responses

19 12 2008
kniterdone

Thanks for the reviews! I can’t wait to buy my first loom. I think I’m going with the Fiddle because we are a military family and I don’t like to spend more money than I have to. I was nervous about the Fiddle before your review.

24 03 2009
String Factory » random/leftover/extra handspun yarn

[...] notions of getting into freeform crochet, but lately I’ve been thinking of trying out a Rigid Heddle Loom. Because, you know, what I *really* need in my life is yet another fiber [...]

2 01 2011
2010 in review « River City Weaves

[...] The busiest day of the year was April 26th with 148 views. The most popular post that day was Rigid Heddle Loom Review updated. [...]

3 01 2011
rivercityweaves

Numerous people have contacted me to find out where these looms could be found at these prices. Please check the original date of the review. It’s several years old. The loom information is fairly constant. Prices; not so much.

28 11 2013
Donna Boggs

Do you know anything about the Cricket? Many people have recommended it to me as a first loom. I haven’t been able to find reviews though. Thanks!

29 11 2013
rivercityweaves

The Cricket is a great little loom. If it fits your needs buy it!

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s




Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 26 other followers

%d bloggers like this: